Cold Cases

Tikeisha Nicole Cottingham

CASE #: 03-10698

INCIDENT: Murder

DATE: March 20, 2003

LOCATION: 1106-B Nokomis Ave, Salisbury, MD 21801

NARRATIVE: On March 20, 2003, at approximately 0400 hours, Deputies responded to 1106B Nakomis Ave, Salisbury, Wicomico County, Maryland for a reported homicide. Upon arrival, Deputies located Tikeisha Nicole Cottingham deceased inside the living room of the residence. Investigation revealed that Cottingham died as a result of multiple stab wounds.

This case is open and actively being investigated by the Wicomico Sheriff’s Office Criminal Investigation Division. Detectives are asking anyone with information, regardless of how insignificant the information may seem, to contact the Criminal Investigation Division at (410) 548-4898 or Crime Solvers at (410) 548-1776. Information leading to the arrest and prosecution of the individual(s) responsible could lead to a reward from Crime Solvers.

Susie Faye Stiltner

CASE #: 12-003854

INCIDENT: Missing Person

DATE: October 9, 2012

LOCATION: South Salisbury area, MD

NARRATIVE: On October 9, 2012 the Wicomico County Sheriff’s Office took a Missing Person Report for Susie Faye Stiltner, DOB 11/14/1969. Through investigation, it was determined that Stiltner was last seen in the South Salisbury area, in August of that year. Stiltner has not been located for almost 10 years and is presumed deceased.

To date, the case is still open and being investigated by the Wicomico County Sheriff’s Office Criminal Investigation Division. We are asking that anyone with information contact the Wicomico County Sheriff’s Office Criminal Investigation Division at 410-548-4898 or Crime Solvers at 410-548-1776. Information leading to the arrest and prosecution of the individual(s) responsible could lead to a reward from Crime Solvers.